Wednesday, September 9, 2009

Lessons Saad Hariri Should Have Learnt By Now

It is no more a secret to anyone who or what is blocking the formation of the Lebanese government thanks to the “move” that Premier-designate Saad Hariri made a couple of days ago when he nominated the country’s new cabinet, with enough arrogance to name the Free Patriotic Movement’s “ministers”.

The choice of the names that Hariri picked from FPM and the Change and Reform parliamentary bloc were not naïve. They were, in fact, carefully studied, as the whole formula was designed to put FPM in front of the fait accompli while betting that alleged internal FPM issues would be its passport to success. Of course, his maneuver backlashed.

But of course, the Premier-designate is new to political life, just the same as he is new to the concept of a country called Lebanon that he only knew after the death of his father, the late prime minister Rafik Hariri. So apparently Hariri the son, oftentimes if not always ill-counseled by his numerous advisers, is totally ignorant of democratic party dynamics where political competition is key, but where the interests of the country prevail. What he also ignores is that however attractive and appealing public office is, FPM politicians and partisans never succumbed to its temptations in the past, nor will they in the future.

As such, the choice of Alain Aoun was meant to infuriate Gebran Bassil, knowing that the two figures are highly ranked at FPM; the choice of Farid Khazen was meant to offer the Kesrwan MP a temptation that was supposed to work double the impact, since is not a registered party member; the choice of General Edgard Maalouf was meant to enrage General Issam Abou Jamra after his defeat in the parliamentary elections. Of course, the plot failed and solidarity was reassured and confirmed by all those involved and by the Change and Reform bloc.

But who was candid enough to believe that the Cabinet would be formed soon after the elections and that the request made by the opposition to have proportional representation to parliament will be met? Why would it be met? Why would Hariri please General Michel Aoun? After all, didn’t he, with his allies, ranging from the United States to Saudi Arabia, make all efforts, used and abused the system, employed every kind of corrupt maneuver during the elections to try to wipe General Aoun out of the political map?

It has become clear that systematic Saudi-brokered attempts to undermine the Christians of Lebanon, through their main representative, are ongoing and the same objectives are still being fought, only in different times and different scenarios. These attempts can be summarized as follows:

First, at the root of the Lebanese war was the Palestinian issue: The Palestinians were given the green light to have a substitution state in Lebanon and they tried expanding through the Christian region, which led the Christian Lebanese Resistance to fight them while the whole world watched. The West, of which Lebanon’s Christians were always “accused” by their fellow countrymen of being “affiliated” with, just left the Christians to battle their own demons throughout 15 years of war.

Second, in 1990, the Saudi-brokered Taef agreement that stripped Lebanon’s Christians from their basic rights and transferred powers to the Sunni prime minister: With the approval of the Maronite Patriarch and while the whole world watched (again!), the Syrian troops raided the Christian area committing all kinds of massacres, and General Aoun was forced into exile. You know the story. They thought this was the end of Lebanon’s Christians and they were wrong. The international community was still watching… but “sympathetically” (it is important!).

Third, 15 years of exile and marginalization of Christians from political life: Lebanon was under occupation, and as Hariri’s successful cabinets were busy embezzling and squandering public funds, young university students were arrested, tortured, and imprisoned. The international community was still watching! No sorry, not watching… turning a blind eye.

Fourth, after the “awakening” of the ill-fated so-called Cedar revolution: The international community insisted on having “democratic and free” elections held under a law enacted under the occupation, just to make sure the Christians are still submitted to the same fate as they had been for 15 years. No journalist, no analyst wondered or asked the following question: how would the French people have felt had General De Gaulle held elections in France after WW2 according to a Nazi law? But of course, the international community has other standards for Lebanon. And while they watched, we won a sweeping victory…

Fifth (and I am only recounting key events), came the 2009 elections: this time, all resources had to be used and abused: money, intimidation, Diaspora, and then again, money and money and money, in elections that will go down in history as the most corrupt ever. These elections were meant to put an end to FPM and the Christians of Lebanon. Unfortunately, the huge amounts of money did not wipe FPM and General Aoun out of the political map. Oh I almost forgot, the international community was watching- to say the least. But this time it was acclaiming the “peaceful, free, and democratic” elections!

So after all this, who still believes that Hariri had the intention of forming a real national unity government?

But if I were him, I would learn one lesson, at least: I would stop wasting time and hurting the country with useless attempts that fall in the same category of the above-mentioned events. If I were him, I would understand once and for all, that the rules of the game have changed. If I were him I would acknowledge that there is an unbeatable, incorruptible party in this country that he will never get rid of. And I would understand that for those people who faced the tanks of the occupier and the whole world unarmed using their own bodies as shields (while he was in some country enjoying his time), for those people who relentlessly stood up for all they believe in, for those people, standing up to Saad Hariri is a piece of cake!

28 comments:

  1. Well done
    Spot on analysis.
    I am not Aouni, by the way.
    This should not just be published on the FPM website but also on newspapers and also other websites to ensure spread of message.

    Joseph

    ReplyDelete
  2. so true, I completely second what Mr. "Anonymous" said...

    ReplyDelete
  3. haki Faadi, you are basing your critic on the notion that the FPM cannot and should not be challenged. His excellency Saad Hariri has clearly stated that he will not appoint Jubran Bssil because he failed in the election. Beside What have the FPM been doing for the last 76 days or so since Saad Hariri was chosen? Why have not they nominated or provided a list? The one who is acting in arogance is Oun and his party, unfortunately they have shown their greed and power hunger. Lebanon is a country that can only be governed with the a series of concessions and not rigidity from all sides. Hariri has shown a lot of flexibility but the FPM has deviated from their original path and imposing their political views. with all my respect, a piece of "bla bla bla" and but what should I expect from the Press Secretary of General Aoun.

    ReplyDelete
  4. You people lost the elections.why cant you stay home.FPM among all parties should be the most civilized one.All of its leaders have been in france and europe.But No, you have been swept away with corruption and you are now no better than any of the other political parties.FPM should know a thing or two about democracy.they know that opposition stays home.this country is maskhara. if was in saad hariri's shoes. i would have formed a government without any of you. and go fuck your self.

    ReplyDelete
  5. plus. the only way that this shit hole,you call a country can only fixed, if it were to be occupied by america or some european country. for like 30 years or so. its like privatization, but on a country level.
    Force the laws. and let the authorities gain power again.and teach the corrupt people some manners and make them civilized and then one day. when lebanon is ready to become a country.they give it back its independence. quite easy and its your salvation . and please stop writing those long self repeating, never ending, same bullshit essays that you hear everywhere and you read everywhere. be real . talk real.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Question: why are the aounist and their allies under the notion that only the general is the savior of the Christians?????? what about the rest of the politicians that also ar working for the interrest of the Christians??? Or are they not good enough cause they do not wear Orange 365 days a week!!!!!!!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  7. 1. Re. what Mr. Anonymous said: "His excellency Saad Hariri has clearly stated that he will not appoint Jubran Bssil because he failed in the election."
    I recall that "His Excellency" Fouad Siniora appointed "Minister" Nassib Lahoud in the last government and as I recall, Lahoud had been swept away in the 2005 elections by FPM in Metn. So why did Future Movement choose now to use this alibi? Why these double standards? People are not stupid and have a perfect memory...

    2. They chose to marginalize Gebran Bassil because of the great achievements in his ministry. In less than 2 years, he was able to cut down rates, and collect government revenues more than any other minister. He has proven that "When there's a will, there's a way" = There was no will before with Marwan Hamade. The only will he had was to embezzle more funds, increase tariffs and maintain mob domination. They marginalized Gebran because he was the living proof that when FPM is in public office, change happens. They marginalized Gebran because he shed light on their corruption.

    3. To the gentleman saying that "opposition stays at home", I am sorry to remind him to read the Lebanese constitution based on "consensus democracy" = dimoukratiye tawafoukiye...

    ReplyDelete
  8. Fortunately, your are not Mr Saad Hariri.
    thanks God

    ReplyDelete
  9. Good morning,

    1. In answer to Mr. Rami. You have suggested our country is governed by the US, as they're the symbol of democracy. With all respect to you Sir, I ask you to notice what is happening in the world due to US governance and correct your information. In their war on terrorism, their badly unorganized agenda concerning Afghanistan and their interior policy -to cite only a few-, the US have failed to provide a model to other countries as per democracy and civilisation. The US can't even control Harlem, so how about Afghanistan and other countries? If this is the way the US act, I understand why as a country, we're not moving forward and why as a government, we are failing.

    2. As per staying home. Allow me to remind you, Sir, that in the most so-called democratic and civilized countries, the Opposition has an impact on the implementation or reject of any Law or project. Take for example the health care reform in the US, or on a european scale, the Lisbon Treaty ratification.

    3. Talking about civilisation, why don't you review your dirty offensive language, or didn't your mother teach you good manners? If you reflect the image of the party you follow, then shame on Lebanon, and yes I do not believe we will ever get to progress if we don't even know how to properly communicate in the first place.

    ReplyDelete
  10. You said "If I were him, I would...". The thing is you are not him, because if you were him, you would have no say in anything whatsoever, you would be under the influence of Saudi Arabia and therefore would be doing what would benefit them and not us.
    You, on the other hand, and all Aounists, are free and this is something that infuriates everyone else.
    I am sure that not for one second you would even want to be him, if you could.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Mr. Anonymous,

    If Hariri is against placing those who failed in the gov't, then why did he nominate Gebran Bassil for a "Wizarit Dawle"? It's either you are completely against or you are lying.

    Second, if you would be so kind as to state the concessions Hariri made to General Aoun, I would appreciate.

    Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  12. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  13. In reply to Ms. Rhéa
    Please note that,i dont reflect the image of any party nor any religious sect.
    i was once carried away by the FMP reform campaign. fortunately i am not a parrot and i dont follow parties or political figures blindly.and also i still do have my logic and a bit of awareness and sense of civilization to note that the FMP was too swept away by corruption.

    And since everyone is corrupt and the citizens are more corrupt and since we dont have an army that respects itself. and since no one abides by the law.
    And the Premier-designate doesnt even have the balls to stand against some whining hooligans who call themselves opposition.

    For the above mentioned reasons,we need to privatize everything,on a country level. and if you now too consider America as the "devil". then i dont mind any European country governing us.
    One more thing: "Please do not be offended, what so ever by anything i just said, i say it because im honest and thats what i think. and i respect the way you thing. and i love the debate."

    ReplyDelete
  14. Diamant
    Very well done May,it highlights whats really going on in Lebanon ,and some lebanese they dont want to hear nor believe ... I wish I can share these informations with the American community I am living in ,because most of the American, they are not aware of whats really going on in Lebanon, the real situation ,because their mass medias tell them the twisted story.any way ,you should publish this article abroad ,to help the world understand ,and I will do my best here .thanks alot ,keep spreading the truth.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Perhaps an Arabic version should reach more people ... cause its worthwhile Very good job.
    Keep up the good work.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Saad Hariri don't want to learn anything.

    He thinks that what they apply in KSA:

    " Lebanon is a land that his father purshased" and Saad owe this land as the living in this land".

    But be sure that as his father and his mafia failed during 15 years at least to apply this slogan, Saad will fail too.

    Both failure are due to the existence of a historic leader like General Michel Aoun and the free patriot movement, who resisted and will continue to resist to these mafias and slaves of the ennemies of our country.


    Paul

    Canada

    ReplyDelete
  17. Paul , you are like a parrot .listen to yourself. you are just repeating what you hear on Otv man.
    what did saad hariri, ever do wrong man. respect and shame. the man doesnt have blood on his hands like all political figures now in lebanon.including your fanatic general.
    plus his father , reconstructed this country.w if it wasnt for his father. downtown would have still been filled with garbage and rats and open sewers and the chi3a occupying it.and if you know well and use logic and common sense instead of blind support to your general. you would know. that most of hariri's major project to fix this country including oza3i and da7eye were stopped because of hizballah . and the syrians have robbed us for 15 years or more.
    and before you say anything . go claim the land of the christians in haret hrek ya batal.
    you people are unbelievable.
    its a shame to know . the people like you went to college and graduated. it aches me to see intellects so blindly ignorant.
    i am an atheist in a durzi society , and im aware enough to say fuck you walid junblat you are shit. "it doesnt take balls , it takes common sense"
    i plead you dont be parrots and copy paste the speeches of your political leaders. be real. talk real.
    dont hate saad hariri, just because michel aoun hates him. unfair. what did the man. do to you

    ReplyDelete
  18. Morning !

    In answer to Mr. Rami.

    1. Saad Hariri may not have blood on his hands, he may have never done anything wrong, nevertheless he is not doing enough. There is no difference, Sir, between not doing anything wrong and not doing enough. In both cases, there is a lack of effort in doing what is right. Yes he has built the DT, but did his efforts stretch out to other Lebanese regions - including his or his allies' regions? No. Take for example the highway linking Beirut to Chweyfat. Take for example Kalamoun - where his photos are raised, hanged on posters. Indeed, his work area only extended to the little cirlce Downtown Beirut is, while the surroundings were left untouched. Notice Sir, that in order to build this Downtown, people were kicked out of their homes and offered a scarce price in return.

    2. Saad Hariri may have constructed a modern DT, still that DT reflects his high-class society. Take a look at the stores, do you actually think a regular Lebanese could afford the price of a single item there? In the past, DT Beirut was open to everybody, now it only addresses an elite of rich people, were they Lebanese or foreigners. Please do not get me wrong; I am not against building a DT that reflects well the image of Lebanon on the international scene, but the builder has to bear in mind that this project has to extend to all Lebanese in the first place, not only to tourists or rich people.

    3. Syrians have robbed us? You are right. Rafik Hariri accumulated $50B-debt because of his policy. Every single newborn is endebted with +$12000. Could each Lebanese afford paying this tax? Could you, Sir?

    4. Have you noticed Sir, that your life is entangled with the famous Truth? Where did this lead the country and its citizens? Where did this lead you personnaly? Nowhere. There is no Truth. Lebanon has been living in a latent, stagnant state, waiting for some UN-investigator to uncover it - who ended up fleeing the country.

    5. Concerning the Southern Suburb and the Shi'a. Whatever your point of view may be, you cannot but pay respect to the Resistance and the sacrifices it has made for this country, especially in the South, when in couterpart, Saad Hariri, Fouad Siniora, Walid Jumblat - to cite only three - were perfectly safe outside the country. Sure, why not? After all, they have the money while the people was starving on the ground.

    6. No matter how repulsively you may talk about the Shi'a, they constitute a great part of the population and won their seats in the Parliament. They cannot be denied their presence and participation in Lebanese politics. Taking the Southern Suburb as Headquarters may enrage some, but Hariri is not doing less in Koraytem, where normal people are beaten every day when they request entering the Haririan fortress - at times only for work. Is this acceptable?

    7. As per the European governing us. Which country would you pick for this noble task? France: corruption and warfare (Only 2 days ago, Nicolas Sarkozy signed a deal with Brazil selling them a Rafale-jet. We're not escaping of war and bloodshed). Italy: Berlusconi is accused of sexual abuse. Switzerland: a bank-scandal made the news a week ago. Which country could fit for the post? Make a suggestion, please. If the European Union as an entity is failing to raise one united voice as per their own matters and affairs, would that make them eligible to govern us?

    ReplyDelete
  19. It is shamefull to see " Illetratred in politics" like Mr Rami speaking.

    In fact, Saad Hariri, is the son of Rakik who stole our country , including the downtown of Beirut, that you are saying he built it.

    If Rafik Hariri, built it from his personal money, please show us the bills Ramie to pay them to Saad. But,if the policies of Hariri's families and their mafia and supporters worldwide brought our country to a defecit of $ 55 Billions at least till now, we should ask about the thieves who stole us , as it is our right of citizens.

    How could a Lebanese ask " strangers to ocupy our country? In which cultures , did you learn this topic Ramie? Only thinking about this issue is a trahison .

    Then, are proud of Americans, who stole the world , when they took trillions in the actual " financial crisis", to cover their messy companies and banks?

    What is disappointing is to see lebanese people becoming illetrated in politics ,as the sample shown by Mr Ramie.

    Paul
    Canada

    ReplyDelete
  20. Looking at the comments above, I have seen Pam asking questions about " other politicians working for christians".

    I see Pam like Ramie another sample of "illitrated in politics".

    For your knowledge Pam, General Aoun is the savior of Lebanon and all Lebanese people , and not only the christians.

    Could you explain to me " what other politicians did for christians", other than killing them on roads , and stoling them byb tax, and supporting the occupation in the past, and now the Mafia who stole our country?

    When will be thinking as Lebanese citizens, and not Christians or muslims, Pam?
    The religion is a direct relationship betweeen the person and his god, and has nothing to do with politics.

    Paul
    Canada

    ReplyDelete
  21. Okay reading all the communications on this blog shows a wonderful plethora of opinions assured me that the possibility to express my opinion freely while respecting all your opinions. I perceived from reading the article and several of the comments on this blog that the attacks are directed towards late Rafic Hariri. My dear bloggers, Saad Hariri is the current political representative of the Sunni community of Lebanon. This was demonstrated in the election results. Call the election what you want and call it a global war against the Aounis and General Aoun in particular. You have been calling for a true representation of the Christians and I am totally for a true representation for all sects in Lebanon including the Sunnis. The Aounis have expressed several criticisms against elections regulations and luckily, they have won, under both mandates the representation of the majority of the Christians. I also want to recall, that Future Movement, under both mandates. For instance, if you observe the election results in Saida, where Prime Minster Sanyoura was running against Ossama Saad, the candidate supported by the opposition and financed by Hezbollah, Prime Minister Sanyoura managed to win a land slide victory against Ossama Saad. The voting difference between both candidates was more than 10,000 votes. At least this is a small demonstration of how much Future Movement represents the Sunni. Just to remind you, that in the Municipal election of 2004, when a domestic and Syrian war was fiercely waged against Hariri, the slate that was suppored by Hariri lost, yet the marginal difference between the lower candidate on the winning list and the list supported by Hariri was about 1500 votes.

    The article above is an attack against the Sunni of Lebanon, which is not new. The Aoun party has been vocal against all Sunni political leaders and against the Sunni community. For instance, when General Aoun formed his government after the Parliament failed to elect a President, His Excellency Prime Minster Aoun did not choose any Sunni politician for his cabinet. General Aoun was among the first to oppose freedom of speech during this era. He threatened to shell any newspapers that failed to mention Prime Minster or President before his name. If you guys have forgot, the Sunnis were the first to protect Lebanon and are the first to stand for the sovereignty of Lebanon. The era of the Syrian presence in Lebanon demonstrated a series of misfortune for all Lebanese, but do not forget that the strength of the Syrian came from an armed group.

    ReplyDelete
  22. cont. above.

    Recall when late Hariri invited General Aoun to return to Lebanon, the first person to come out and oppose this initiative was President Berri. And of course an orchestra of Syrian loyalists played on many instruments against this initiative. I have respected the Aouni when they stood against the Syrian oppression and said No, at a time where, I and many people like me feared even opening our mouths. The one who tasted the feeling of oppression should be the first to embrace the ones that are feeling the same feeling.

    Hariri group and allow me to say the Sunnis were the first to be marginalised and threatened under a Syria controlled Lebanon. Just remember that Hariri was the only politician under attack. A war was waged against him simply because he his representing the Sunni of Lebanon. As the President represents the Christians of Lebanon and the Speaker of the House represents the Shia of Lebanon, like it or not, the Prime Minister Office represents the Sunnis. Late Hariri was the political representative of the Sunni of Lebanon. Late Hariri could not appoint any (Sunni) person in many positions in any of the Lebanese Government offices. On the other hand, if you survey most of the government departments and especially in Saida, Hariri’s hometown, most of the appointed public servants are not Sunnis.

    Unfortunately, I came to a conclusion that for some reason, intentionally or not intentional, the Sunnis of Lebanon have been under attack and many attempts have been waged to make them feel inferior ( May 7). The Sunni of Lebanon (Generally Speaking and not narrowing it to the Hariri family, just to make things clear) are a major segment of the Lebanese fabric and it is for the Sunni’s broad and wide contacts with the Arab and the Muslim world, Lebanon has achieved its prestige and trust in the Arab world. and No one can ignore the role of the Christians have played in the Western world. Of course the Shia were part of the Sunni community and they deserve a respectable representation. The decision that Imam Musa took for the Shia to have a deserved representation was holy.

    The concession that Sheikh Saad has shown is by nominating Gebran Bassil as (Wazir Dalwa) He did not marginalized nor ignored FPM. I believe that all the obstacles that the opposition has been showing are to weaken Saad Hariri’s endeavour to form a coalition government and undermine his position. The leading Sunni political leaders have shown tremendous for Saad Hariri and have declared that he is the only person fit to form a government and I guess now it is no longer necessary to form a coalition government with the opposition. The opposition has spoken and shown its intentions to abide to rigid and inflexible initiatives.

    Ziad Sorry could not include the entire opinion. My first post was from Anonymous starting with Haki Fadi.

    ReplyDelete
  23. ramie and pam are 2 stupid persons. I will not bother to answer those 2 nullities.

    ReplyDelete
  24. In my previous comments, I said that I am disappointed to see how " Lebanese people" became unfortunately " Illetrated in politics".

    Unfortunately, this feeling is increasing, specially when I see somebody like the two previous comments without " a name", maybe because the person is shy of his name .

    In fact, until Lebanese people reach the level to tell themselves " Lebanese citizens", our country will continue its free fall.

    The person(s) with the 2 previous comments are speaking about " Sunni" and christians, like if our country Lebanon is a combination of 18 or 19 several small " religious countries" ( One for christians, another for Druze, a third one for sunni, a fourth one for Shiia aand etc...)

    A president, a prime minister, or a speaker are persons who represent " Lebanon" and not their religions. The religion is a relationship between a person and god.

    Then, nobody insulted " the sunni". In fact, the opposite happened as the sample done few days ago by Mount- lebanon " Mufti Ali Joujou" by saying " that General Aoun is the ennemy of sunnis". How this religious person discovered this ennemy? In which book is it written?

    In the end of the day, remembe that " Rafik Hariri" was not more than a collaborator with the syrians when they were occupying our country in the past.

    The rael reason of the few fighting between this Rafik Hariri and the syrians " were for business reason", and sample are a lot in the archives as proof.

    Paul
    Canada

    ReplyDelete
  25. Dear Paul,
    Insulting a Mufti that represents a relgious position and has his position in the Sunni community of Lebanon whether he is popular or not shows that you guys " Aounis" hate everthing related to the Sunni community and definity shows your political ignorance. dividing people between those who understands politics and those who do not is as you have described the " other". Yes Lebanon as Ziad Rahbani called it " haydi ortet 3alam majmou3een" Yes every presidential post in Lebanon represents a sect and every politician represents his sect. His has been confirmed with all of General Aoun but calling for a better representation of the Christians. Also we want a better representation for all in the country until we are able to reach to a point where we all can seize to abide to our sectarian divisions. Anyways The path is long. The reason why I believe that there is a systematic war against the Sunni, is that when I heared a very close acadamic to General Aoun praising the May 7th event and that the event was necessary for the Sunnis to feel inferior raises so many questions and....\
    Ziad

    ReplyDelete
  26. Sunni should be ashamed of having to vote "Zayyi ma hiya" and be imposed upon, by the "Khadem al harameyn al sharifeyn", their leader since oil sprout out of the desert.
    Sunnis should be ashamed for collaborating with the Syrians and for using the palestinians against their lebanese brothers.
    We christians do not wait for the vatican or some other instances to name our leader or trace our policies. We are not a sect my dear Anonymous and we are free people. FREEEE!!!, do you know what that means? I can see your startled face when you are reading this. If you do not learn to be FREE , you will never be considered as lebanese. So work on it and prove yourself !
    May God bless you and open your eyes.

    ReplyDelete